This is a three-part story of three women from three different time periods, drawn together by a combination of events over time. I know that’s very vague, but there’s not much more I can say about this without giving away huge parts of the plot. It’s about immortality, and toxic relationships, and the ways that unlimited time and unlimited hunger twist and warp a person from who they once were.
I’m not sure how to review this one. I suppose I can start by saying that it was an incredible book. It drew me in immediately and kept me captivated the whole time. The distribution between the three stories was a bit uneven, but I didn’t mind so much. I never caught on to the source of the immortality until it was revealed. My brain has been wrapped up so much with soul-hopping and reincarnation stories recently, so I don’t know if I just missed obvious cues or if the story was clever enough to hide the reveal quite well. In any case, I was clearly just along for the ride.
There were two quotes that really hit home for me, especially coming out of a longterm situation that was really not good, which becomes clearer the longer I’m away and seeing things from an outside perspective. When you’re stuck in a bad situation, you often don’t see all the little things keeping you there – you’re too focused on trying to hold things together, never questioning if you should be trying, or if it’s worth saving. So these two quotes hit me powerfully. The first:
It is easy, isn’t it, in retrospect? To spot the cracks. To see them spread. But in the moment, there is only the urge to mend each one. To smooth the lines. And keep the surface whole.
And the second:
Why does Charlotte stay? That is like asking—why stay inside a house on fire? Easy to say when you are standing on the street, a safe distance from the flames. Harder when you are still inside, convinced you can douse the blaze before it spreads, or rushing room to room, trying to save what you love before it burns. [emphasis added]
It was generally a very powerful book, a masterpiece of a tale. I’ve seen some reviews where people say the end is dissatisfying or anticlimatic, but I completely disagree. I think it’s a perfect ending, exactly what I’d hoped for. It made me love everything that came before even more.
Performance: This book was read by Marisa Calin, Katie Leung, and Julia Whelan. All three narrators were good, but I especially loved Katie Leung’s performance. Possibly because I just love the Scottish accent so much. (But also, she and the others all did great with a multitude of accents!)



















