Coraline (graphic novel), by Neil Gaiman

coralineI’ve now read the original book, seen the movie, and read the GN version of Coraline. Of them all, I think the GN is actually my favorite. I thought the medium worked well for the story. My biggest quibble with the actual book was that the plot all seemed too simple, too easy for Coraline to overcome obstacles, but the GN format streamlined the story so that it seemed less like that. Instead, it felt more like a modern fairy tale, with triplicate tasks and a fitting climax. I really enjoyed it.

Posted in 2010, Children's, Visual | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Proof by Seduction, by Courtney Milan

proof-finalThis is my first ever Harlequin romance novel, and honestly the only one I’ve ever wanted to read. A couple years back, I saw the query pitch for this book on an agent’s blog and loved it so much I decided to read the book one day, even if it’s completely out of my comfort zone. Funny thing is, I thought the book was very well done – except for the sex parts. Something about explicitly-described sex is a complete buzzkill for me. I prefer more indirect implication, gliding around the actual act, rather than “members” and “passages” and all the other traditional romance-sex language. Beyond that, it was actually an interesting story, almost a Pride & Prejudice-like setup, though there was some waffling of character at the end that got a bit tedious, as if the second half needed some more editing. I doubt I’ll read another Harlequin novel, but this one turned out to be better over all than I expected, which was nice. Thanks to Tasha for sending me a copy!!

Posted in 2010, Adult, Prose | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

The Tapestry of Love, by Rosy Thornton

tapestry-of-loveDivorced and with her children grown and out of the house, 48-year-old Catherine Parkstone leaves England and settles into a mountain home in Southern France, where she plans to set up a business in tapestry.

I know that doesn’t seem like much of a summary, but I don’t want to say more and give anything away. I honestly hardly know how to write about it. I suppose I should start by saying that it was absolutely the book I needed right now while I’m under so much stress. It was warm, comforting, and homey, and the prose was beautiful without ever jarring me. I needed something comfortable and soft, and this book gave me that.

I love Rosy Thornton’s writing. I adored it in Crossed Wires, which was one of my favorite books from last year and which I loved even more on reread this year, and I knew it would be the same in her other books. When she wrote to offer me a copy of this book for review, I accepted immediately. I found everything I expected inside it: beautiful language, a complete immersion into the setting, and characters so real they feel like people, not fiction.

Setting. If you’ve been around my blog for any amount of time, you know that setting and landscape description is really difficult for me. Long passages of landscape cause me to zone out, and I don’t like huge amounts of any sort of description. With Thornton’s writing, it’s different. She knows exactly how much detail to put in, without overloading the reader or trying to describe every single thing. She paints a picture – a touch of color here, another touch there – and lets your mind fill in the rest. Her descriptions never got tedious, boring, or tiring, and I could really see and feel the world of Cévennes and St. Julien. It’s been 11 years since I lived in France and it was beautiful to revisit.

Then there were the characters. The characters make this story, more so because the plot is absolutely unremarkable. I don’t say unremarkable to mean boring or plain – I mean that there is no sweeping glorious story with stressful climax and resolution, like there is in many books. The things that happen to the characters here are things that happen in real life. People die when they get old or severely ill. People fresh out of college struggle with their career choices. People fall in love or out of love. Relationships get started and/or break up. People travel. They struggle with their taxes. They trade services with their neighbors.

On top of all that, Catherine Parkstone is adjusting to life in France. She has to adjust to a new language, culture, climate system, and cuisine. The book takes place over a year, and she slowly goes from her awkward first steps to a confidence that only comes with time. She grows and learns. Some of the first scenes are revisited in the last, and the differences between them sharply define this contrast. It was wonderful.

And then there was the primary romance of this book. Just like with Crossed Wires, it was a slow and understated romance, built on a lot of time and friendship. There’s caution between people who are older, who have been married and divorced in the past, who have had lives before this time and are not as incautious as they might have been at 20 years old. But there is also still passion and feeling and love. There is hurt and betrayal and misunderstanding as well. The Tapestry of Love explores all of that. And I have to say when Patrick calls Catherine “Cat-rine. Chérie” I completely melted away. Perhaps it was knowing how it sounds in French, but the words were so lyrically romantic that they really touched me.

Last little thing I want to talk about, and then I’ll end this – I loved the way the French was handled in this book. It’s been years since I could speak French well enough to get by, but I love being able to read little bits. I love that there was enough in here to touch on the language and idioms, but that there was never any haggle over direct translations that you see in some books. The French flowed into the text, just another element woven into the tapestry that makes up this book (a silly statement, perhaps, but still true). I’m not sure I can say I liked this one more than Crossed Wires, which had a certain personal appeal based on my own history with my husband, but I did completely fall in love with it by the end and I imagine it’s one I’ll revisit sometime in the future.

Posted in 2010, Adult, Prose | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (graphic novel), by Robert Louis Stevenson

jekyllWhile of course this graphic novel version of Jekyll & Hyde can’t quite live up to the original text, which is one of my very favorite books, the illustrator did an excellent job capturing Stevenson’s tone and atmosphere in his illustrations. The whole book was cloaked in this perfect soft-sketch style, dark and haunting. I really enjoyed it. It’s one of the best GN classics adaptations I’ve read. Plus! – I was really happy it left in my very favorite line: “If he be Mr. Hyde, than I shall be Mr. Seek.” 😀 It’s so cheesy I can’t help but love it!

Posted in 2010, Adult, Visual | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Ruined, by Paula Morris

ruinedI liked the story of this book, though there were elements of the plot that seemed off or odd. The setting was very well done. It was a lot simpler in writing than I was expecting – more like middle grade than young adult – so that threw me a little. It made for a fun afternoon reading, and I did learn some good things about writing and technique from it, which is a plus. I don’t have much else to say about it.

Posted in 2010, Prose, Young Adult | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Readathon: Mercury, by Hope Larson

mercury_larsonThis story is twofold. In 1859, a prospector named Asa shows up on the Fraser family farm in Nova Scotia. He entices Mr. Fraser with gold, and wins the daughter, Josey’s, heart. In present day, the Fraser descendants still lived in the same home on the same land until their house burned down a couple months back. Tara Fraser is struggling to deal with that and starting school after two years of being home-schooled by her mom. The two stories collide, one ending in tragedy, and one in hope.

I really liked Gray Horses when I read that for Readathon last year, but I think I liked Mercury even more. The story wasn’t quite as surreal (though it did have a few of those moments), and I liked seeing how the two stories unfolded and tied together. Unlike with most twofold stories like this, I didn’t favor one story over another. Both equally interested me and I was equally invested in them. I also adored the artwork. This made a very good Readathon book and I was very happy I made the last-minute decision to grab it from my library the day before the event!

Posted in 2010, Visual, Young Adult | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Readathon: Good Omens, by Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett (audio)

Good-Omens-339743Good Omens is a humorous look at the apocalypse. It involves an angel, a demon, the Antichrist, the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, a children’s gang, a fortune-teller/Jezebel, a witch-finder association, a Satanic Order of Chattering Nuns, a Hell-hound, and Agnes Nutter, the witch who wrote the Nice and Accurate Prophecies which predicted the end of the world. Of course, there are many others involved too, but this gives a good spread of characters so you can see just what sort of book Good Omens is.

I listened to this book on audio and had a splendid month doing so! This book reminded me so much of Dogma the movie, only completely its own, too. I think it’s surpassed all the other Gaiman books I’ve read to become my favorite (as well as my favorite Pratchett, but it’s only the second of his I’ve read). I’m sure I missed a ton of references, both because of the format, and because of the very Mystery Science Theatre-like qualities, with references heaped upon references heaped upon references. It was so funny. Listening to it on audio was brilliant. Martin Jarvis was the reader and I loved all the voices he made for each character. You always knew who was talking when, which is amazing considering the vast number of characters here! My only quibble with the audio version was there was no pause between section breaks, which was sometimes unsettling. I got used to it after awhile, but I do wish there had been more indication of when we were changing sections, especially when a section was only a sentence or two long. But other than that very minor issue, the audio was perfect and I loved it. I definitely need to get my hands on my own copy of this book, and I’m still trying to decide if I should do it in print or audio (or both).

Posted in 2010, Adult, Prose | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Readathon: Ghost Cat, by Beverly Butler

ghostcatAnnabel is spending the summer with her great-aunt and -uncle and a bunch of cousins she’s never met. She would rather be at home with her mother, and feels very out of place on the lonely Wisconsin farm. But soon she hears the crying of a cat and sets off after it, and a mystery begins to unravel.

This was a childhood favorite of mine. I loved revisiting it for Readathon and RIP!! It’s the sort of book I read hundreds of times when I was a little girl. A couple years ago, I was reminiscing about it, and Jason went and found me a copy for Christmas! With the same cover I had as a kid and everything! I’ve now read it twice since that Christmas.

I have no idea if it’s really a “good” book. I’m too biased to be able to evaluate it that way. At least one of my sons has read it and liked it, though, so I guess the fact that it’s older (1984) doesn’t make it inaccessible now. It’s certainly dated in some respects, and you’d expect a children’s book to be, but even so, I still get a small thrill of terror as Annabel discovers the ghost cat and the circumstances of its death. I love watching her get to know a family she never knew (both the ones she’s staying with, and the ancestors she’s never known about). And I especially loved the cozy little Wisconsin setting. It reminds me of my brief home there in the early 2000s.

Note: Originally read in ~1988-ish.

Posted in 2010, Children's, Prose | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

Readathon: A Doll’s House, by Henrik Ibsen

dollshouseNora’s very happy. Her husband has just gotten a better job with a higher salary, and soon she’ll be free of a debt she incurred many years ago (without her husband’s knowledge) to finance a trip south that saved her husband’s life. But then the person who gave her the loan shows up. He’s being fired by Nora’s husband and tells her he will reveal everything if she doesn’t influence her husband to change his mind.

Okay, so I know that setup sounds a bit boring and lame, perhaps, but really, this play is worth reading and/or seeing. The whole time I was reading, I thought the play was pleasant and interesting, but not this really striking story that people always talk about. It was very easy to read, with very modern, flowing language despite a translation from the Norwegian and the fact that it was published in 1879. Altogether I thought it was fun and mildly interesting, but not amazing. When I got to the last few pages, however, it became that striking story. The next paragraph will be all spoilers, so if you want to walk away now, that’s okay – just know this play is really, really amazing and I highly recommend it. Also, for those of you out there interested in Women’s Studies, this is definitely one you want to check out!

Okay. The end. I was expecting Nora to be crushed or for everything to turn out well, probably the former. What I wasn’t expecting was Nora’s suddenly growing in her mind to understand that all she’s ever been to the men around her is a pet, a doll, a plaything. In one moment, because her husband is a real jerk to her instead of being considering, caring, or polite, she suddenly sees everything clearly. I love love LOVE what she says to him, and her decision to just leave. She must find herself and learn how to be a person, rather than a doll. Honestly I don’t even mind her walking away from children she never really did anything for anyway. It’s like she was thrown into a void, and realized she didn’t exist, and the only way to live again was to go find herself. What an amazing message. I was so surprised to find out this was written in 1879, and what a stir it caused then! It feels very modern, with a feminist message that wouldn’t have been out of place in the mid-to-late 20th century. It was so good!!

Posted in 2010, Adult, Drama | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Readathon: The Castle of Otranto, by Horace Walpole

the castle of otrantoManfred is desperate for his only son to wed and carry the family lineage down in the Castle of Otranto. There is a prophecy that says that the Castle will return to its rightful owner when that owner is “too big” to fit in Castle. The book opens on Manfred’s son’s wedding day, with a giant helmet falling from the sky and killing Manfred’s son. The rest of the book is filled with giant limbs, wayfaring priests, hidden catacombs, ghostly spectres, and tainted love.

Sounds fun, eh? The Castle of Otranto was one of the earliest Gothic novels (if not THE earliest), and I was really looking forward to it after loving The Monk. Sadly, it didn’t really live up to my expectations. It’s not that it was a bad book, but it was sort of difficult to read. Like 7-page paragraph sort of difficult. The conventions of dialog at the time weren’t the same as now, so there were no quote marks and no breaks between speakers, so that it was difficult at times to follow who was saying what. I imagine I would have enjoyed it more if I hadn’t been spending all my effort in unraveling the text itself. I wonder if a different edition might have been better…

But even without the textual issues, the story wasn’t very compelling to me. The characters were more in the old-fashioned archetype style rather than having individual characterizations, which has never worked well for me. Then there was the premise. All Gothic novels are meant to stretch the limits of your imagination, but this one stretched it just a bit too far for me. The whole “helmet falls from the sky” thing struck me as slightly absurd in a way that cross-dressing monks and the devil swooping a character across the sky didn’t. I’m well aware that not everyone would have this reaction, that cross-dressing monks and devil-swooping might seem just as (if not more) absurd than giant helmets falling from the sky, but for me, Otranto felt a little contrived. I appreciate what the book did – a genre has to get started somewhere, right? – but altogether it wasn’t my favorite Gothic novel.

Posted in 2010, Adult, Prose | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment